Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> There's more than one kind of mindfulness, and more than one kind of vipassana

Definitely true, by itself sati/smrti is a hard-to-translate term.

> Shamatha is "calm abiding", which I think is what the McMindfulness crowd are trying to teach. It should really be treated as a sort of universal preliminary for most other types of meditation. But it's perfectly reasonable to treat shamatha as your main practice (as I did).

I am mostly focussing on some breathing mindfulness meditation and some metta, not much, but enough that I feel a calming effect, and I overall am trying to foster some 'buddhist values' in my life.

> I was told that chöd is a specifically Tibetan practice; I don't know what it would be called in Sanskrit. It's a visualisation practice, in which you imagine chopping up your body and your senses, and make an offering of them. I've never tried it; I was told it's scary. I was also told it's sutrayana, although the visualisation makes it sound vajrayana. I guess chöd is a kind of vipassana?

I heard of meditating on your 'own decaying body' definitely from a theravada context, but was overall warned that meditation objects from the imagination are more risky overall for psychological emergencies.

> sutrayana

That sounds like Bhante Vimalaramsi?



No idea what Bhante Vimalaramsi is. I used the term as a synonym for sravakayana; I think I probably used it incorrectly, it should probably include a lot of mahayana practice (because mahayana sutras). Maybe it just means "practices that don't depend on revealed teachings". At any rate, "not tantrayana".


Ah, Bhante Vimalaramsi is an american monk originally from the theravada tradition who IIRC uses Sutrayana for his take on what the Pali canon says, as he deviates from the theravada interpretation of the text.


"Sutrayana" meaning "not Vajrayana" is typical for Tibetan Buddhism.


after a good nights sleep, I think I mixed up pali / sanskrit and the monk I am referring to surely considers himself "Suttayana" :-)

I never really looked into Tibetan buddhism tbh.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: