Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Agree 100%. The problem is really, GDP is in one currency. There should be a second metric, adjusted to local buying power, for countries with loads of internal resources, and production capability.

When I look at numbers, for example, which China spends on military spending, and research? Then try to equate it not in USD, but in local buying power?

And also consider many Chinese companies are state owned, including resources (mining), refining, and producing weapons...

Compared to almost everything the US GOV and the West do, being for profit...

It seems to me that China's military budget dwarfs all of NATO, in terms of buying power.

Yet most seem to not consider this. Even in planning.

US air superiority means little, if each US plane costs 40x a Chinese plane, and each US plane is swarmed by 100 planes at once...

(Just an example, viable or not)



> There should be a second metric, adjusted to local buying power, for countries with loads of internal resources, and production capability.

There is, it's called GDP PPP (Purchasing Power Parity). It adjusts for local prices, so countries like Russia and China rank higher than they would at a nominal level. Keep in mind though global commodities are typically priced the same (or similar) worldwide; PPP only applies to goods produced internally.


GDP PPP is a more accurate measure. It factors in what things cost locally. The scales start to balance out more when looked from that angle.

Even then, some places like Afghanistan don't change much--and they're still completely unbeaten by modern militaries.


There's a difference between political failures and military ones. Apples and oranges. No amount of military power can compensate for a lack of (or unachievable) political goals.

Korea, Vietnam, and Afghanistan all lacked coherent political goals. "Destroy military forces supported by half the country" is not a valid strategy.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: