Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Well, if the dragon exists it must have the characteristics of a dragon. Let's say it must be an animal with four legs and a tail. Currently it's unknown whether all animals are q-conscious[1]. Let's say it is discovered that all animals are q-conscious. Therefore the invisible dragon is q-conscious.

Currently we don't really understand qualia, but one mainstream theory is that qualia are a different kind of thing to anything else we know about (i.e. are non-physical).

Let's say this theory is true, and, further, that a method for detecting this different kind of thing is detected. That the dragon is invisible, floats, is heatless, is incorporeal, doesn't matter.

The theory that there is a dragon in the garage is falsifiable by the observation that a scan for qualia results negative.

You could say "ah, but this dragon is the dragon of any-test-you-can-come-up-with-doesn't-work, therefore you can't come up with any test which would work". But that would be begging the question.

[1]That is, all animals have qualia.



Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: