Right, that’s why I specifically said “monetary incentive”. There will always be non-monetary reasons to create content.
Are you proposing that trying to make money using the internet is morally wrong? Or just that collecting user data is wrong? Or that collecting data without consent and a clear explanation is wrong? Because if the line is drawn at the latter, then that’s what GDPR is for, and so I don’t understand why people would be upset about having to click through a bunch of notices that try to make it clear how user data is being used.
The problem is that there's no actual consent, just simulacra. The GDPR doesn't say that you just have to "make it clear how user data is being used", it says the user must freely give consent, which means they must not only explicitly do so, as not giving consent must not mean the user loses access to services or content (see Recital 43).
Are you proposing that trying to make money using the internet is morally wrong? Or just that collecting user data is wrong? Or that collecting data without consent and a clear explanation is wrong? Because if the line is drawn at the latter, then that’s what GDPR is for, and so I don’t understand why people would be upset about having to click through a bunch of notices that try to make it clear how user data is being used.